CASE STUDY: PUBLIC DEBT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN BOTSWANA
CASE STUDY: PUBLIC DEBT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN
BOTSWANA
To Download tutorial
Copy and Paste below Link into your Browser
for any inquiry email
us at ( essayblue@gmail.com )
Case
study: Public Debt and Economic Growth in Botswana
Objective
The pedagogical
objective of this empirical assignment is to explore the relation between data
that are gathered
by a
survey for a developing country and the variables that are employed in
published studies.
the
Eviews file (.wf1) and the electronic document copy (.doc) of your assignment
should be attached.
You are
given the following details for Botswana:
Country’s
Profile
Government
type: parliamentary republic
Independent
since 1966 (British colony)
Capital:
Gaborone
Population:
1.949 million
Currency:
Pula
GDP per
capita:$13,100 in 2010
Income:
upper middle
Growth
rate (2009): -5,6% (generally positive &high)
Life
expectancy: 54 years/ 2nd in the world in cases of HIV (ages between 15-49)
Land:
Kalahari desert covers 85% of the country-only 15% is inhabited
Economy:
diamonds(3rd in the world-the world’s most diamond-dependent economy), tourism,
agricultural
sector
accounts for only 4% of GDP (due to droughts)
difficult to diversify theà lack of workers with
technical/managerial skills àInfrastructure:
satisfactory
economy
«Switzerland
of Africa» , continuous peace/political stability helped Botswana to be ranked
as the country with
the
greatest economic development in the world–9.2% on average-for the period 1966
– 1997
Source:
nationsencyclopedia, 2010
General
policies
Between
1966-1997: adoption of a conservative investment policy that actively sought
foreign capital for I
(investment)
in crop agriculture, tourism and secondary industries.
1997-
:affected by the Asian crisis, thenceforth: high rates of 1)unemployment (20%,
2009), 2)inflation, 3)
poverty
(Gini index=0,63)
2003- :
diversification/encouragement of FDI in non-mining sectors, including
light/pharmaceutical industry,
tourism,
financial services
2008-
affected by the world crisis- reduction of public sector
Source:
nationsencyclopedia, 2010
According
to the last report of IMF (2007), Botswana had done quite well in:
↓ public
sector
maintaining
π near to 3-6% (Central Bank’s goal)
keeping
neutral political stance in the interest rate determination,
improving
public administration,
widening
the tax base,
educational
reform
In the
current report of World Bank, it is emphasized the need to further:
1.
Reduce the public sector from 40% to 25% of GDP
2.
Ameliorate infrastructure
Botswana
and IMF
*Joseph
Stiglitz (who used to work for IMF and WB) in his book Globalization and its
Discontents (2002) he
points
out that Botswana’s success rested on its ability to maintain a political
consensus, based on a broader
sense of
national unity.
*Government
& outside advisers that came from a variety of public institutions and
private foundations, were
the main
reason why the country made it on its own way.
*Unlike
the IMF these advisers explained their policies to obtain popular support for
the programs and
policies(
open seminars /one-to-one meetings with cabinet ministers and members of
Parliament)
*IMF
→1981: the organization found it very difficult to impose new conditions
because Botswana had already
done so
many of the things that they would have insisted upon. Since then, Botswana has
not turned to the
IMF for
help.
Following the right path
Botswana’s economic development has been financed by domestic resources rather than by capital or aid
inflows from abroad. National saving has been relatively high and has steadily increased over the years, thanks
to the robust growth in diamond revenue until the recent crisis and to the government’s sustained effort to
build up reserves by running fiscal and current account surpluses. As a result, national saving has not been a
constraint on the financing of domestic investment.
Evidence from Research
[Filled by you] – Please refer to Step 1
Botswana and the recent world economic crisis
In late 2008, the world crisis triggered an important reduction of diamonds demand and therefore of diamond
production which caused GDP to fall sharply in the first quarter of 2009. Non-mining sectors of the economy
were less affected. Meanwhile, the government starts to tightening spending to ensure long-term fiscal
sustainability. So as not to aggravate the recession, the government followed moderately anti-cyclical fiscal and
monetary policies. Only a few development projects were cut or postponed as a result of the tight fiscal situation
To finance its development projects, the government contracted a general budget support loan of 1.5 billion
US dollars (USD) from the African Development Bank (AfDB) in 2009.
Source: Globserver , 2010
Thirty (30) observations of time-series data (t=1980-2009) are available for the following variables: y: real GDP
(at constant prices), i: investment, l: labor force, d01: external debt. The country that you examine is Botswana.
A time-series model with the following linear functional form is created:
gry=β0 + β1 i_y + β2 grl + β3 ratiod + u
where gry: the growth of real GDP (at constant prices),
where i_y: the ratio of the investment share of real GDP,
where grl: the growth of labor force, and
ratiod: the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
Reminder: You will need to hand out your results (graphs, outputs, etc) in a hardcopy and in an
electronic copy.
Please do the following:
1. Review the paper [Iime, A. 2006, “Did Botswana Escape from the Resource Curse?”, IMF, African
Department, pp. 1-33] and write a brief summary (maximum 2 pages) addressing the following:
Research Question, Data, Identification Strategy, Methodology, Results, Conclusions. This step fills
the section “Evidence from Research”.
2. An excel data file is available to you (Data.xls). Import the data to Eviews and save the file as
7021X_LastName_FirstName.wf1. Be sure to specify your data series by YEAR.
3. Generate new variables for the growth of the real GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force
and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
4. Generate natural logarithms (log in Eviews calculates the natural logarithms) of the growth of the real
GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and
the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
5. Show Descriptive Statistics (obs, mean, std dev, min, max, etc.) of your variables for Individual Samples.
6. Show the Histograms for each of the following variables: growth of the real GDP (at constant prices),
the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and the ratio between external
debt and real GDP.
7. Show the Correlation Matrix (from Covariance Analysis) of the following variables: growth of the real
GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and
the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
8. Show the Histograms for each of the following natural-log versions of the variables: growth of the real
GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and
the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
9. Show the Correlation Matrix (from Covariance Analysis) of the following natural-log versions of the
variables: growth of the real GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the
investment share of real GDP and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
10. By checking the histograms that you created, comment on the nature of the distributions (symmetry,
asymmetry, tails) between the regular variables and their natural-log versions. Based on your answer,
decide between a linear functional form of your model and a natural-log functional form and choose
which one you are going to use. *Hint: Another way to answer this question is to compare between the two models
by model-building tools.
The following questions are based on the model you chose at Step 10.
11. Graph the time series plots of each of the following variables: growth of the real GDP (at constant
prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and the ratio between
external debt and real GDP. Comment on each of the plots you graphed. Can you make a connection
of the highs and lows that you observe with historical events?
12. Graph the scatter plot between the growth of the real GDP and the ratio of the investment share of
real GDP (with fit line: regression line).
13. Graph the scatter plot between the growth of the real GDP and the growth of labor force (with fit
line: regression line)
14. Graph the scatter plot between the growth of the real GDP and the ratio between external debt and
real GDP (with fit line: regression line).
15. Comment on each of the scatter plots in Steps 12, 13, 14 regarding the correlation between each group
of variables.
16. Regress the growth of the real GDP (at constant prices) on the ratio of the investment share of real
GDP, the growth of labor force and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
17. After you regress the model in step 15, plot its actual, fitted, residual graph.
18. Plot the actual, fitted, residual graph for each of the following variables separately: the growth of labor
force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
19. Test significance at a 5% significance level of each independent variable on the dependent variable of
your model in Step 15. Comment on the power of the significance of each independent variable on the
dependent.
20. Test the overall significance at a 5% significance level of independent variables on the dependent of
your model in Step 15.
21. Detect if multicollinearity exists and if it exists try to remedy it.
22. Detect Heteroscedasticity of your model if it exists, by making use of the Park Test, the BreuschPagan-Godfrey Test and the White Test with and without cross terms and comment on your results.
In case Heteroscedasticity exists, try to remedy it either by using Generalized Least Squares or by using
Weighted Least Squares. Why do you think heteroscedasticity exists/ not exists in your model?
23. Detect if autocorrelation of your model exists and in case it exists try to remedy it.
24. In case autocorrelation exists, plot the actual/fitted residuals of your new model and of your new
independent variables separately and compare with the plots in Steps 17 and 18. What do you observe?
Sources
www.nationsencyclopedia.com
http://www.globserver.com/en/press/bostwana-and-financial-crisis
www.imf.com
http://data.worldbank.org/
References
Stiglitz, J. 2002, Globalization and its Discontents, WW Norton, New York & London
Iime, A. 2006, “Did Botswana Escape from the Resource Curse?”, IMF, African Department, pp. 1-33
Fowewe, B. 2008, “Financial liberalization policies and Economic Growth: Panel Data Evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa”,
African Development Bank, vol.20, no.3, pp. 549-574
Psarommati Vasilikoula, Master Thesis, 2011, University of Piraeus
Following the right path
Botswana’s economic development has been financed by domestic resources rather than by capital or aid
inflows from abroad. National saving has been relatively high and has steadily increased over the years, thanks
to the robust growth in diamond revenue until the recent crisis and to the government’s sustained effort to
build up reserves by running fiscal and current account surpluses. As a result, national saving has not been a
constraint on the financing of domestic investment.
Evidence from Research
[Filled by you] – Please refer to Step 1
Botswana and the recent world economic crisis
In late 2008, the world crisis triggered an important reduction of diamonds demand and therefore of diamond
production which caused GDP to fall sharply in the first quarter of 2009. Non-mining sectors of the economy
were less affected. Meanwhile, the government starts to tightening spending to ensure long-term fiscal
sustainability. So as not to aggravate the recession, the government followed moderately anti-cyclical fiscal and
monetary policies. Only a few development projects were cut or postponed as a result of the tight fiscal situation
To finance its development projects, the government contracted a general budget support loan of 1.5 billion
US dollars (USD) from the African Development Bank (AfDB) in 2009.
Source: Globserver , 2010
Thirty (30) observations of time-series data (t=1980-2009) are available for the following variables: y: real GDP
(at constant prices), i: investment, l: labor force, d01: external debt. The country that you examine is Botswana.
A time-series model with the following linear functional form is created:
gry=β0 + β1 i_y + β2 grl + β3 ratiod + u
where gry: the growth of real GDP (at constant prices),
where i_y: the ratio of the investment share of real GDP,
where grl: the growth of labor force, and
ratiod: the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
Reminder: You will need to hand out your results (graphs, outputs, etc) in a hardcopy and in an
electronic copy.
Please do the following:
1. Review the paper [Iime, A. 2006, “Did Botswana Escape from the Resource Curse?”, IMF, African
Department, pp. 1-33] and write a brief summary (maximum 2 pages) addressing the following:
Research Question, Data, Identification Strategy, Methodology, Results, Conclusions. This step fills
the section “Evidence from Research”.
2. An excel data file is available to you (Data.xls). Import the data to Eviews and save the file as
7021X_LastName_FirstName.wf1. Be sure to specify your data series by YEAR.
3. Generate new variables for the growth of the real GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force
and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
4. Generate natural logarithms (log in Eviews calculates the natural logarithms) of the growth of the real
GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and
the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
5. Show Descriptive Statistics (obs, mean, std dev, min, max, etc.) of your variables for Individual Samples.
6. Show the Histograms for each of the following variables: growth of the real GDP (at constant prices),
the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and the ratio between external
debt and real GDP.
7. Show the Correlation Matrix (from Covariance Analysis) of the following variables: growth of the real
GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and
the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
8. Show the Histograms for each of the following natural-log versions of the variables: growth of the real
GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and
the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
9. Show the Correlation Matrix (from Covariance Analysis) of the following natural-log versions of the
variables: growth of the real GDP (at constant prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the
investment share of real GDP and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
10. By checking the histograms that you created, comment on the nature of the distributions (symmetry,
asymmetry, tails) between the regular variables and their natural-log versions. Based on your answer,
decide between a linear functional form of your model and a natural-log functional form and choose
which one you are going to use. *Hint: Another way to answer this question is to compare between the two models
by model-building tools.
The following questions are based on the model you chose at Step 10.
11. Graph the time series plots of each of the following variables: growth of the real GDP (at constant
prices), the growth of labor force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and the ratio between
external debt and real GDP. Comment on each of the plots you graphed. Can you make a connection
of the highs and lows that you observe with historical events?
12. Graph the scatter plot between the growth of the real GDP and the ratio of the investment share of
real GDP (with fit line: regression line).
13. Graph the scatter plot between the growth of the real GDP and the growth of labor force (with fit
line: regression line)
14. Graph the scatter plot between the growth of the real GDP and the ratio between external debt and
real GDP (with fit line: regression line).
15. Comment on each of the scatter plots in Steps 12, 13, 14 regarding the correlation between each group
of variables.
16. Regress the growth of the real GDP (at constant prices) on the ratio of the investment share of real
GDP, the growth of labor force and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
17. After you regress the model in step 15, plot its actual, fitted, residual graph.
18. Plot the actual, fitted, residual graph for each of the following variables separately: the growth of labor
force, the ratio of the investment share of real GDP and the ratio between external debt and real GDP.
19. Test significance at a 5% significance level of each independent variable on the dependent variable of
your model in Step 15. Comment on the power of the significance of each independent variable on the
dependent.
20. Test the overall significance at a 5% significance level of independent variables on the dependent of
your model in Step 15.
21. Detect if multicollinearity exists and if it exists try to remedy it.
22. Detect Heteroscedasticity of your model if it exists, by making use of the Park Test, the BreuschPagan-Godfrey Test and the White Test with and without cross terms and comment on your results.
In case Heteroscedasticity exists, try to remedy it either by using Generalized Least Squares or by using
Weighted Least Squares. Why do you think heteroscedasticity exists/ not exists in your model?
23. Detect if autocorrelation of your model exists and in case it exists try to remedy it.
24. In case autocorrelation exists, plot the actual/fitted residuals of your new model and of your new
independent variables separately and compare with the plots in Steps 17 and 18. What do you observe?
Sources
www.nationsencyclopedia.com
http://www.globserver.com/en/press/bostwana-and-financial-crisis
www.imf.com
http://data.worldbank.org/
References
Stiglitz, J. 2002, Globalization and its Discontents, WW Norton, New York & London
Iime, A. 2006, “Did Botswana Escape from the Resource Curse?”, IMF, African Department, pp. 1-33
Fowewe, B. 2008, “Financial liberalization policies and Economic Growth: Panel Data Evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa”,
African Development Bank, vol.20, no.3, pp. 549-574
Psarommati Vasilikoula, Master Thesis, 2011, University of Piraeus
Comments
Post a Comment